7 Best Toothpastes with Baking Soda & Peroxide 2026

This is a game-changer for anyone battling gum sensitivity or early signs of gingivitis. ARM & HAMMER Peroxicare delivers a clinically proven punch with its dual-action formula combining baking soda and hydrogen peroxide, targeting plaque bacteria at the gum line while reducing redness and bleeding in as little as two weeks. The low-abrasion design means it cleans deeply without sacrificing enamel integrity—perfect for those who want aggressive plaque removal but fear over-scrubbing. If your gums feel tender after brushing or you’re prone to inflammation, this toothpaste speaks directly to that pain point.

In real-world use, the 6.0 oz tubes (pack of four) offer long-term value, and the Clean Mint flavor leaves a crisp, not overpowering freshness that lingers without numbing your taste buds. It foams moderately, ensuring even distribution, and works well with both manual and electric toothbrushes. On tough surface stains—from coffee or tea—it shows gradual improvement over 3–4 weeks, though it’s not marketed as a heavy-duty whitener. Where it truly excels is in daily gum maintenance, especially when paired with flossing. However, those with extreme sensitivity may still find the peroxide kick slightly intense at first.

Compared to Colgate’s baking soda variants, this one prioritizes gum health over flashiness, trading bold whitening claims for measurable periodontal benefits. It’s more specialized than Crest’s value-focused offerings, which lack clinical backing for gum support. Ideal for users who see their dentist regularly and want a preventative, science-backed formula, it balances therapeutic action with everyday usability. For gum protection paired with gentle whitening, it outperforms rivals that focus solely on surface brightness.

If your morning routine demands a burst of freshness that feels like a deep dive into icy mint, this Brisk Mint formula from Colgate delivers a sensory jolt like no other in the category. The baking soda and hydrogen peroxide combo doesn’t just sit idle—it activates on contact, releasing pure oxygen bubbles that create a tingling clean sensation, lifting away overnight residue and food particles with satisfying efficiency. It’s not the strongest whitener here, but its refreshment factor is unmatched, making it a top pick for people who equate oral care with a wake-up call.

At 5 ounces, the tube size is practical for daily use, and the formula spreads smoothly without excessive foaming. It tackles surface stains from light coffee or soda drinking with consistent use, showing visible results in about three weeks. Brushing feels thorough, and the low-abrasive texture respects enamel while still scrubbing effectively. That said, it doesn’t offer clinical gum health claims like ARM & HAMMER’s version, and long-term whitening is modest—think maintenance, not transformation. If you’re dealing with deeper discoloration or smoker’s stains, this won’t be your miracle worker.

Positioned between basic pastes and medical-grade options, this Colgate strikes a balance between refreshment and functionality. It’s simpler than the twin-pack Frosty Mint variant but more accessible than niche brands. Compared to Crest’s budget-friendly option, it offers a more vibrant flavor profile and better stain removal, though at a slightly higher cost per ounce. Best suited for adults who prioritize a minty clean mouth feel and light whitening over therapeutic gum support. When freshness is non-negotiable, this one earns its keep.

This Frosty Mint twin pack from Colgate doesn’t just freshen—it invades your mouth with a polar wave of coolness that lasts well past the sink. Engineered for those who crave a luxurious brushing experience, it leverages baking soda and peroxide to generate micro-oxygen bubbles that penetrate plaque and disrupt surface stains with each brush stroke. The sensation is immediately gratifying, almost spa-like, making it a standout for users who view oral care as self-care. With 12 total fluid ounces, the twin-pack format ensures long-term supply without compromising freshness.

Performance-wise, it excels in daily plaque disruption and maintains a bright smile with consistent use. The 6-ounce tubes are generous, and the paste dispenses evenly, lathering just enough to signal action without waste. It removes light coffee and wine stains over time and leaves breath crystal-clear for hours—a win for social confidence. However, like most Colgate variants, it lacks clinical data supporting gum health improvements, and while it fights cavities, it doesn’t go as deep on preventive care as ARM & HAMMER’s Peroxicare. Sensitive teeth may also react to the intense cooling effect initially.

When stacked against the Brisk Mint version, this Frosty Mint offers a smoother, more refined flavor experience—less sharp, more layered. It outshines Crest’s value packs in sensory appeal and stain management, though it doesn’t match ARM & HAMMER’s gum-focused science. Ideal for flavor connoisseurs and routine upgraders, it turns brushing into a ritual rather than a chore. For those who want a premium feel with solid whitening action, it’s the most enjoyable ride in the category.

For the frequent traveler, sample enthusiast, or routine rotator, this 6-pack of 2.5 oz tubes is a logistical dream—compact, portable, and perfect for maintaining consistency across multiple locations. Colgate’s Brisk Mint formula returns here with the same oxygen-bubble activation and baking soda scrub, delivering that familiar crisp clean with every use. The small size makes it ideal for gym bags, work desks, or hotel drawers, ensuring you never skip a brushing session due to convenience. It’s also a smart choice for households testing different pastes without committing to full tubes.

Each mini-tube performs like its larger counterpart: removes surface stains, fights plaque, and freshens breath with that signature tingling peroxide lift. The formula is gentle on enamel and effective for daily maintenance, though not designed for rapid whitening transformations. Because of the small capacity, cost per ounce is higher than bulk options like the twin pack or ARM & HAMMER’s 6 ozers—so it’s not the most economical for full-time home use. Still, the convenience factor is unbeatable, especially for those with dynamic lifestyles.

Compared to Crest’s 2.4 oz budget option, this Colgate version offers better flavor, stronger stain removal, and brand reliability. It lacks the gum health focus of ARM & HAMMER but compensates with versatility and portability. If you’re someone who brushes on the go, shares paste across bathrooms, or likes to switch formulas weekly, this pack is engineered for your rhythm. For frequent use in multiple settings, it beats larger tubes in flexibility, even if it costs more over time.

When maximum whitening intensity is the mission, this Extreme Whitening formula from ARM & HAMMER steps into the ring like a heavyweight contender. Packed with a concentrated dose of baking soda and hydrogen peroxide, it aggressively targets years of accumulated surface stains from coffee, wine, and smoking, unleashing pure oxygen bursts that bleach discoloration at the molecular level. The 4.3 oz tube may be smaller than others, but every squeeze is potent and purpose-built for users who want visible change in two to three weeks. If you’ve tried milder whitening pastes with underwhelming results, this one delivers the kick you’ve been missing.

In testing, it produces a robust foam that clings to teeth, ensuring prolonged contact with stain-lifting agents. Brushing feels slightly more abrasive than other options—still enamel-safe, but not ideal for daily long-term use if you have sensitivity. It whitens effectively, often showing a noticeable difference within 10 days, especially on extrinsic stains. However, it lacks the gum health benefits of the Peroxicare line and doesn’t advertise cavity protection with the same rigor. For those with gum recession or exposed dentin, the peroxide may cause temporary zings.

Compared to Colgate’s whitening variants, this packs a stronger punch and outperforms in speed and depth of results. It’s less about refreshment and more about transformation—a tool, not a treat. While Crest’s value packs offer gentler alternatives, they can’t match this level of stain obliteration. Best for users preparing for events, touch-ups between professional cleanings, or those committed to a whiter smile without strips or trays. If whitening power trumps all, this is your apex predator.

This dual-pack offering from Crest is the smart shopper’s secret weapon—delivering solid performance without stretching the budget. With baking soda and peroxide in the mix, it tackles surface stains and tartar buildup with quiet efficiency, making it ideal for those who want no-fuss, reliable results over flashy promises. The 5.7 oz tubes (two included) mean you’re covered for months, and the formula is gentle enough for twice-daily use, even for those with mild sensitivity. It freshens breath effectively and maintains a clean mouth feel, hitting all the basics without overreaching.

In real-world use, it removes light stains from daily beverages and helps prevent new tartar formation along the gum line—especially useful for back molars prone to buildup. The paste spreads easily, foams moderately, and doesn’t leave a gritty aftertaste. While it won’t deliver Hollywood-level whitening like ARM & HAMMER’s Extreme Whitening, it maintains brightness and supports long-term dental health. Its biggest limitation? A lack of standout flavor or sensory excitement—this is function-first oral care, not a flavor adventure.

Stacked against Colgate’s Brisk Mint, it’s less invigorating but more economical per ounce. Compared to the single 2.4 oz Crest tube, this pack slashes the cost per use dramatically, making it a smarter buy for households. It doesn’t match ARM & HAMMER’s gum health claims, but for balanced protection and value, it’s hard to beat. If you want dependable, affordable whitening with cavity and tartar defense, this pack earns top marks for practical excellence.

Don’t let the tiny 2.4 oz size fool you—this mini tube from Crest packs the same baking soda and peroxide core as its bigger siblings, making it the perfect entry point for budget-conscious buyers or trial users. It delivers a clean, no-frills brushing experience with gentle whitening action, ideal for removing light morning film and keeping breath fresh between bigger purchases. The formula is enamel-safe and low-irritant, suitable for sensitive users who still want stain removal and cavity defense without spending upfront.

Despite its size, it performs reliably for short-term use—about a week with twice-daily brushing. It tackles surface impurities and minor discoloration effectively, though results build slowly over time. The mint flavor is straightforward, not memorable, but gets the job done without artificial harshness. Where it falters is longevity—using it full-time means frequent repurchasing, which adds up. And while it shares DNA with the larger Crest pack, it lacks the bulk savings and extended protection that make the twin-tube version a better long-term play.

Compared to Colgate’s 2.5 oz multipack, this single tube is cheaper upfront but less flexible. It’s not designed for whitening intensity or gum therapy, but as a low-risk trial or emergency backup, it’s unbeatable. For students, dorm dwellers, or anyone testing baking soda pastes for the first time, it removes the commitment barrier. When budget and size are critical, this little tube proves big things come in small packages.