7 Best Northern Pike Spoons for 2026

This flash-first fury of a spoon delivers one of the most eye-searing presentations in murky water or low-light conditions. The pure silver plating outshines standard chrome finishes, creating a high-intensity flash that mimics injured baitfish with precision. Paired with its 35-degree wobble—a motion that rocks side-to-side without twisting the line—this spoon cuts through water cleanly, making it ideal for targeting aggressive Northern Pike that home in on erratic, reflective targets. It solves the angler’s biggest frustration: lures that go unnoticed in stained or deep water.

In real-world casting and trolling scenarios, the brass blade construction adds heft for longer casts, letting you cover more water with less effort. At 3/4-ounce and 2-3/4 inches, it’s sized perfectly for medium-to-large pike, slicing through currents without fluttering unpredictably. The metal weed guard helps reduce hang-ups in light cover, though it’s not fully weedless—expect occasional snags in heavy vegetation. While it performs admirably behind a steady retrieve, it lacks the lifelike darting action of bent-body spoons when jigged vertically.

Compared to the AL’s Goldfish 49er, this Johnson spoon trades nuanced action for maximum visibility and flash, making it a better choice for dirty water or aggressive top-level strikes. It doesn’t flutter or dart like the 49er on the fall, but its consistent wobble and mirror-like shine dominate in conditions where vibration and light reflection matter most. For anglers prioritizing flash over finesse, this is a no-nonsense weapon that outperforms its price tag when pike are keyed in on brightness.

If you’re building a pike hunter’s arsenal from scratch, this 30-piece kit is a value-packed launchpad that covers nearly every scenario you’ll face on the water. The assortment ranges from 2.56 to 3.35 inches and 4.5 to 9.5 grams, giving you tactical flexibility to match the hatch across seasons and species. What stands out is the vibrant color selection and reflective finishes, which create lifelike swimming actions that trigger reaction strikes from lurking pike, especially in clear lakes and slow-moving rivers.

Field-tested in both freshwater lakes and brackish estuaries, these spoons hold their own with a tight, side-to-side sway that mimics fleeing baitfish—critical for fooling cautious predators. The ultra-sharp treble hooks consistently set well, and the rust-resistant metal body withstands repeated use without pitting. However, some lighter spoons (under 6g) struggle in windy conditions or strong currents, where their lower mass reduces casting distance and depth control. They’re best fished with a steady retrieve or slow troll rather than aggressive jigging.

Against the HESTYA 40-pack, this kit offers slightly fewer pieces but better color-to-size balance and more thoughtful design variation. While HESTYA wins on sheer quantity, this set delivers curated diversity—ideal for anglers who want proven patterns without sifting through duplicates. For beginners or gift-givers, it’s a smart, comprehensive entry point into spoon fishing that outperforms its cost with reliable action and build quality.

This is the definitive Northern Pike spoon—a precision-engineered strike magnet that blends lifelike action, rugged durability, and multi-technique versatility into one elite package. The patented ball chain design is the star here, allowing the 3.5-inch, 1/2-ounce spoon to deliver an incredibly fluid, head-wobble motion that screams injured prey. Whether you’re vertical jigging through ice or casting along weed edges, the action remains consistent across slow, medium, and fast retrieves—something few spoons can claim.

Real-world testing across lakes and rivers shows these spoons excel in cold water and low-light conditions, where pike rely on vibration and movement over color. The solid brass body resists corrosion and maintains its jewelry-grade finish even after repeated use, while the Eagle Claw treble hooks provide reliable penetration. They cast beautifully, troll without wobble-induced line twist, and flutter naturally on the drop. The only limitation? Their premium weight and price make them less ideal for targeting smaller species like panfish.

When stacked against the Johnson SM3/4-SLVR, the IRON DECOY trades raw flash for superior action and adaptability. It’s not just a casting spoon—it’s a four-season, all-technique performer that dominates in ice fishing, open-water jigging, and trolling. For serious pike anglers who demand maximum strike response across environments, this is the best overall spoon in the lineup, offering unmatched performance that justifies its position at the top.

The AL’s Goldfish 49er is a masterclass in versatile lure design, engineered to flutter, dart, and roll with the unpredictability of a dying minnow—exactly what Northern Pike can’t resist. Its bent nose design is the secret: when jigged vertically, it tumbles erratically on the fall and darts off in random directions on the lift, mimicking a disoriented baitfish. On a retrieve, it swims on its back with a tight barrel-roll wobble, creating both flash and vibration that draw strikes in clear or stained water.

In practice, this spoon shines in shallow weed beds, drop-offs, and near submerged structure, where its erratic movement triggers ambush strikes. At 5/16-ounce and 2-1/4 inches, it’s on the lighter side—perfect for finesse fishing—but lacks the heft for long casts or deep trolling. It performs best with stop-and-go retrieves or vertical jigging, though it can be trolled slowly. The stamped brass body is nearly indestructible, and the industrial coating keeps colors sharp, but the small size may be overlooked by larger, more aggressive pike.

Compared to the Dardevle Red Devle, the 49er offers more nuanced action but less raw visibility. While the Red Devle dominates in deep, murky water with its 1-ounce punch, the 49er excels in clear, structured environments where subtlety and movement trump size and flash. For anglers who switch techniques often, this is the most adaptable spoon here—equally effective for trout, walleye, and pike with zero modifications.

For anglers who believe more is better, the HESTYA 40-piece pack is a bulk-bait bonanza that delivers unmatched variety across five key weights—from 1/5 oz to 3/4 oz—making it easy to match any fishing condition. The zinc alloy construction resists rust and maintains a bright, light-refracting finish, while the carbon steel treble hooks offer solid grip and durability. The straight-cut design enhances casting distance, letting you reach distant pike lairs with minimal effort.

In real use, these spoons perform reliably across fresh and saltwater, with consistent side-to-side wobble that attracts bass, walleye, and medium-sized pike. The range of sizes lets you adapt to wind, depth, and target species on the fly—something few value packs offer. However, the action is somewhat generic compared to premium designs like the IRON DECOY; they sway but lack the head-wobble or flutter that triggers reaction bites. They’re best for steady retrieves or trolling, not finesse jigging.

Against the 30-piece kit from the same tier, this set wins on quantity and size diversity, but not necessarily on individual lure performance. It’s not the best for elite pike hunters, but for recreational anglers, families, or charter guides who burn through lures, it’s the best large variety pack—offering broad utility and solid build at a mid-tier price.

The Dardevle Red Devle is a legend in the making—a no-frills, brute-force spoon that’s been trusted by pike anglers for generations thanks to its hammered brass body and iconic red-and-white flash. At a full 1 ounce, it’s built for long-distance casting and deep-water trolling, slicing through waves and current with authority. The hammered texture amplifies vibration and light scatter, while the high-contrast color pattern stays visible even in murky, low-visibility conditions.

Field-tested in rivers and large lakes, this spoon excels when trolled at medium speeds or cast into open water with a steady retrieve. Its simple, straight design creates a moderate wobble—nothing fancy, but effective for triggering follows. It’s not ideal for jigging or fluttering, and the lack of a weed guard means it snags easily in vegetation. Still, when you need to get deep and stay visible, few spoons deliver like the Red Devle.

Next to the Johnson SM3/4-SLVR, it offers greater weight and depth penetration but less refined action. It’s the go-to when simplicity and durability matter most—perfect for beginners or anglers targeting big, deep-dwelling pike. While it doesn’t have the flashy tech of newer models, its proven track record and rugged build make it the best classic design in the group.

Designed for ambush predators in heavy cover, the QualyQualy Weedless Spoon is a game-changer for pike hunters who spend their days fishing around lily pads, weeds, and submerged timber. The integrated weed guard isn’t an afterthought—it’s engineered into the lure’s curved body, allowing it to glide through thick vegetation without snagging, while still exposing enough hook to ensure solid hooksets. At 2.7 inches and 2/7-ounce, it’s light enough for finesse but aggressive enough to draw big strikes.

In testing, the spoon delivers a natural side-to-side rock without rolling or twisting the line, and its bright, coated finish throws off brilliant flashes that mimic baitfish in shallow, sunlit water. The ultra-hard single hook holds fish well, though it’s not a treble—so you’ll need good technique to set it. It performs best with a lift-and-fall jigging motion, where its irregular flight path imitates a wounded fish. However, it’s less effective for long casts or deep trolling due to its lighter weight.

Compared to the IRON DECOY, it sacrifices some open-water versatility for superior cover performance. If you’re fishing weedy backwaters or shallow bays, this is the best weedless design available—offering a rare blend of cover penetration and strike-inducing action that few spoons match. It’s not the all-rounder, but in the right environment, it’s unbeatable.