3 Best KitchenAid Toasters of 2026

This compact powerhouse delivers restaurant-quality toasting in a minimalist footprint, making it a standout for small kitchens and solo toasters. With extra-wide 1.5-inch slots and 7 shade settings, it handles everything from delicate brioche to thick sourdough with impressive consistency. The Little Longer function is a game-changer—no more guessing when your artisan bread needs an extra kick. It solves the daily frustration of uneven toasting and jammed crumbs with thoughtful engineering that feels anything but budget-tier.

In real-world testing, the manual high-lift lever shines, safely elevating even small pastries without risk of burns or tongs. The Bagel setting focuses heat on the cut side while gently warming the outer crust—ideal for everything from Montreal-style bagels to English muffins. While it lacks independent controls per slot, the uniform toasting performance across both chambers ensures reliability. However, the crumb tray is small and may need frequent emptying during heavy use, and the single lever means both slots eject simultaneously.

Compared to the 4-slice KMT4109PL, this model sacrifices capacity but gains countertop real estate and a lower price point—ideal for singles or couples who value precision over volume. It’s not built for big families, but for those seeking reliable, elegant toasting without clutter, the KMT2109 punches above its weight. Against the long-slot KMT4116ER, it’s less versatile with oversized breads but more than sufficient for standard loaves—offering better value for basic needs with premium build quality.

If you’re after unmatched versatility in a sleek, professional-grade package, the KMT4109PL is the definitive all-rounder among KitchenAid toasters. Boasting dual independent 7-shade controls, it lets you toast four slices to two different preferences at once—perfect for households with varied tastes. The extra-wide 1.5-inch slots accommodate thick Texas toast, frozen waffles, and even folded croissants without crushing. With Bagel, Defrost, Reheat, and Little Longer functions, it’s a kitchen multitasker that replaces the need for a toaster oven in many scenarios.

During testing, it consistently delivered golden-brown results across bread types, with minimal variation between slots. The high-lift lever makes retrieving smaller items like English muffin halves effortless and safe. Its even heat distribution prevents hotspots, a common flaw in budget models, and the removable crumb tray is generously sized for a 4-slice unit. That said, the lack of a keep-warm function can be a minor inconvenience when toasting in batches, and the porcelain finish, while elegant, shows fingerprints and water spots more than stainless steel.

Pitted against the KMT2109, this model is clearly designed for families or frequent entertainers who need simultaneous toasting with precision. While it’s bulkier, the dual independent controls justify the footprint. Compared to the KMT4116ER, it lacks the extended slot length for ciabatta or baguettes but offers smarter functionality and superior control. For those who want the most balanced blend of power, precision, and polish, this is the best overall KitchenAid toaster—delivering performance that matches its premium look.

For bread lovers who regularly toast artisan loaves, ciabatta, or baguette slices, the KMT4116ER is a game-changing specialist with its extended 7-inch long slots—a rare feature in the toaster world. These extra-long, 1.5-inch wide slots swallow oversized breads whole, eliminating the need to saw awkwardly at crusty ends. Backed by 7 shade settings and a Keep Warm function, it offers both precision and patience, holding toast at ideal temp while you finish your coffee or fry eggs. The Empire Red finish turns a utilitarian appliance into a countertop statement.

In real-world use, the long-slot design proves invaluable for gourmet breads that crumble when forced into standard toasters. The Keep Warm feature is a subtle luxury—no more cold toast by the third slice. The high-lift lever ensures safe retrieval, and the under-base cord storage keeps countertops tidy. However, it only has one set of controls for all four slots, so you can’t toast two different shades at once. This makes it less ideal for households with mixed preferences, and the lack of a dedicated Bagel mode means you’ll need to manually adjust settings for cut-side focus.

Compared to the KMT4109PL, this model trades independent controls and specialty functions for sheer slot length and aesthetic flair. It’s not the most versatile, but for those who regularly bake or buy long-format breads, it’s unmatched. Against the 2-slice KMT2109, it’s overkill for singles but a dream for bread-centric households. With fewer smart features but superior fit for long breads, it’s the best choice when slot length is non-negotiable—offering niche performance that justifies its place in serious kitchens.