7 Best Jarred Pickles of 2025

There’s a quiet integrity in the 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Fresh Kosher Sandwich Pickle Slices that elevates them beyond the average jarred dill. These thin, crisp slices are crafted from premium organic cucumbers and steeped in a traditional kosher brine with just enough garlic and dill to sing without overpowering—making them a standout for health-conscious eaters who refuse to sacrifice flavor. With no artificial preservatives and a certified organic label, they tackle the growing demand for clean-label pantry staples while delivering the bright, tangy punch sandwich lovers crave.

In real-world use, these pickles hold their crunch remarkably well, even after opening and repeated fridge access, thanks to their vacuum-sealed freshness. The 16 fl oz jar may be smaller than others on the list, but the focus here is on quality over quantity—perfect for weekday lunch prep or garnishing gourmet burgers. That said, their milder flavor profile can get lost in bold sandwiches packed with strong cheeses or spicy sauces, and the smaller size means quicker turnover for larger households. Still, for those prioritizing organic ingredients and subtle, authentic dill taste, they’re a reliable go-to.

Compared to the robust punch of Claussen or the hearty spears from Grillo’s, these 365 slices play a more supporting role—ideal for purists who want a clean, crisp bite without chemical aftertaste. They’re a top pick for organic seekers and families focused on non-GMO, kosher-certified foods. While they don’t offer the heft of larger jars like MT. Olive, they deliver superior ingredient transparency and consistent texture that outshines many budget brands.

Vlasic Sandwich Dill Pickle Chips burst onto the palate with a zesty, vinegary kick and a crunch that resists sogginess—a rare win for mass-market jarred pickles. These ultra-thin chips are engineered for sandwiches, slipping neatly between burger buns and layered club wraps without adding bulk, while their 0-calorie profile makes them a favorite among keto and low-carb dieters. Packaged in a resealable 24 fl oz jar, they promise lasting freshness, and for the most part, deliver—maintaining crispness for weeks after opening, a common pain point with lesser brands.

In testing, these chips proved exceptionally reliable in moist environments, like stacked deli sandwiches or tuna salad, where softer pickles often turn limp. The secret spice blend—a mix of garlic, dill, and a hint of sweetness—adds depth without artificial flavors, though purists may detect a slightly processed edge compared to refrigerated brands. They’re less ideal as a standalone snack due to their delicate structure, sometimes fracturing when bitten directly from the jar. Still, for sandwich-centric eaters, they’re a no-fail garnish that adds brightness and texture in every bite.

Stacked against Claussen’s bolder dills or Grillo’s artisanal spears, Vlasic chips trade gourmet complexity for consistent crunch and convenience. They’re the workhorse of sandwich builders, especially those meal-prepping or feeding crowds. While they lack the organic or refrigerated pedigree of premium picks, their shelf-stable practicality and keto-friendly label make them a smart staple for everyday use.

Amazon Saver Kosher Dill Pickle Spears are the unapologetic budget champion of jarred pickles—delivering a solid, no-frills dill experience at a price that won’t strain groceries. These 24 fl oz spears offer the classic garlicky tang and firm crunch expected from kosher dills, making them a dependable choice for families or bulk snackers. While they lack the organic or gourmet labels of pricier rivals, they nail the basics: vinegary bite, consistent texture, and reliable refrigerated freshness—all without flashy packaging or inflated cost.

In real-world testing, the spears hold up well as snackable sticks or lunchbox add-ons, though they’re slightly less crisp than Claussen or Grillo’s after repeated jar openings. The brine is adequately seasoned, but not particularly complex—missing the layered spice notes of premium brands. Still, for everyday use—on charcuterie boards, alongside sandwiches, or as a quick salty bite—they deliver solid performance without pretense. The resealable lid helps, though it’s not as airtight as higher-end jars.

When weighed against Claussen or MT. Olive, Amazon Saver wins on affordability and accessibility, though it clearly trades off flavor depth and brand prestige. These are not pickles for connoisseurs, but they’re ideal for cost-conscious households or anyone who burns through jars quickly. While they don’t match the gourmet profile of Grillo’s or the boldness of Claussen, they offer surprisingly decent quality for the price—a rare win in the value segment.

Grillo’s Pickles Classic Dill Pickle Spears enter the jarred pickle arena like a gourmet underdog with a clean-ingredient manifesto—and they back it up with a crisp, vibrant crunch and a brine so bright it lingers on the palate. Made with just 7 whole-food ingredients and no artificial preservatives, these spears deliver a handcrafted taste that feels worlds apart from mass-market brands. The 32 fl oz jar offers generous volume, but the real story is in the clean, robust dill flavor—garlicky, herbal, and perfectly balanced—making them a favorite among health-focused foodies who crave boldness without compromise.

In performance, Grillo’s spears retain their firmness even after days in the fridge, resisting the mushiness that plagues lesser pickles. The low-calorie, high-satisfaction profile—only 5 calories per spear—makes them a go-to for keto, low-sodium, or mindful eating plans. They shine as a standalone snack or alongside charcuterie, though their thicker cut can dominate delicate sandwiches. The only real flaw? A slightly weaker seal on the jar, which may lead to brine leakage if not stored upright.

Compared to Vlasic’s thin chips or Amazon Saver’s budget spears, Grillo’s leans into the premium, small-batch experience—closer in spirit to refrigerated deli pickles than shelf-stable giants. They’re the pick for flavor purists and ingredient detectives who want a gourmet edge. While they cost more than Claussen or MT. Olive, they offer cleaner sourcing and superior taste—a trade-off worth making for pickle enthusiasts.

Claussen Kosher Dill Pickle Halves are the gold standard of jarred pickles—a benchmark of crunch, flavor, and freshness that consistently outperforms competitors. Crafted with vine-ripened cucumbers and pickled in a signature spice blend featuring garlic, turmeric, and red pepper, they deliver a bold, tangy kick that’s both sharp and satisfyingly complex. Being always refrigerated, they retain a crispness that shelf-stable brands can’t match, solving the #1 complaint about jarred pickles: sogginess.

In real-world use, these halves excel in sandwiches, burgers, and as party snacks—their half-cut shape makes them easy to grab and stack without rolling. The 32 fl oz resealable jar offers ample supply for families or gatherings, and the brine stays flavorful over time, never turning flat or overly salty. They’re slightly tangier than Vlasic and more robust than Amazon Saver, though their strong flavor might overwhelm delicate dishes. The only caveat? They require fridge space, which can be a hurdle for those with limited cooling.

When measured against Grillo’s gourmet profile or MT. Olive’s bulk size, Claussen strikes the perfect balance of taste, texture, and versatility—earning their “Best Overall” title. They’re ideal for everyday eaters, grill masters, and pickle purists who want reliability without compromise. While not organic like 365 or as low-cal as Vlasic, they offer unmatched all-around performance—a true benchmark in the category.

MT. Olive Kosher Dills stand tall with a towering 46 oz jar—the undisputed king of bulk value in the jarred pickle world. This isn’t just a jar; it’s a pantry powerhouse built for families, delis, or anyone who goes through pickles like water. The full spears are firm and well-brined, offering a classic dill punch with garlic and vinegar at the forefront—nothing fancy, but reliably satisfying. With 4.25 lbs of pickles in one container, it’s the ultimate choice for minimizing grocery trips and maximizing savings.

In practice, the pickles maintain a decent crunch for a shelf-stable brand, though they don’t quite match the snap of refrigerated Claussen or Grillo’s. The brine is salty and assertive, which some may find overpowering if eaten straight from the jar. Once opened, the lid seal isn’t the tightest, so freshness can degrade faster if not consumed promptly. Still, for sandwich bars, cookouts, or institutional use, the sheer volume and low cost-per-ounce make it a logistical win.

Compared to Claussen’s premium freshness or Amazon Saver’s mid-tier balance, MT. Olive wins purely on scale and economy. It’s not for gourmet snackers or ingredient purists—but for high-volume users and value hunters, it’s unmatched. While it lacks the refrigerated crispness of Claussen, it delivers maximum pickle for minimum effort—a true workhorse in large-format form.