9 Best Hamilton Beach Toaster Ovens of 2026

This game-changing combo delivers the perfect balance of affordability and performance, making it a standout in the crowded air fryer toaster oven space. With 1400 watts of power and Sure-Crisp convection technology, it crisps fries to golden perfection and bakes evenly—no more cold spots or soggy bottoms. The roll-top door design is a true innovation, staying out of the way during use and making it easy to check on food or add ingredients mid-cook, solving the common frustration of bulky doors blocking countertop space.

In real-world testing, this model handles everyday meals with ease—air frying frozen tater tots comes out consistently crispy, while baking a 12-inch pizza results in a perfectly browned crust without hotspots. It fits six slices of toast with room to spare and maintains stable temperatures across all four functions: air fry, bake, broil, and convection. However, it lacks a dedicated pizza setting or rapid preheat, so those looking for speedier cycles may feel limited. The 30-minute timer with Stay On is great for longer cooks, though advanced programming options are missing.

Compared to higher-end models like the 31395, this one trades searing power and grill functionality for simplicity and value. It’s not built for high-heat indoor grilling, but it excels as a no-fuss, reliable workhorse for small families or individuals who want air frying and baking in one compact unit. If you’re after maximum bang for your buck without sacrificing core performance, this Hamilton Beach model outshines pricier rivals by focusing on what matters most: consistent results and user-friendly design.

Meet the ultimate indoor grilling powerhouse—this Hamilton Beach 31395 doesn’t just air fry; it sizzles with 450°F searing heat, delivering outdoor-grill-level char and flavor right from your countertop. With 1700 watts of power and a nonstick ribbed grill plate, it transforms burgers, steaks, and veggies into restaurant-quality meals in minutes. The Sure-Crisp air fry mode ensures crispy wings and fries with minimal oil, while the six digital cooking modes make it a true all-in-one appliance.

During testing, the grill function proved exceptional—six 4 oz. burgers cooked evenly in under 10 minutes, with juices sealed in and a satisfying crust formed. The 0.88 cu. ft. cavity handled a full 8 lb. turkey with ease, and the dual pour spouts on the grill plate made cleanup a breeze. However, the learning curve for optimal grilling settings can be steep for beginners, and the oven doesn’t preheat as quickly as some competitors. Still, for those craving bold, grilled flavors year-round, this model delivers where others only hint.

When stacked against the B0949DJ2LN, this unit offers significantly more power and versatility at a higher cost. It’s not the most compact or budget-friendly, but if indoor grilling is your priority, the trade-off is worth it. For families who love grilled meals but lack outdoor space or time, this Hamilton Beach oven redefines what a countertop appliance can do, combining grillhouse performance with air fry convenience in one sleek package.

This premium performer earns its “Best Overall” title with a bold 1750-watt engine, crisp-inducing Sure-Crisp technology, and an extra-large viewing window that transforms cooking into a visual experience. The offset handle and panoramic glass door let you monitor food without opening the oven, preserving heat and ensuring even results. Whether you’re air frying chicken wings or baking a casserole, the convection fan circulates heat flawlessly, delivering golden exteriors and juicy interiors every time.

Real-world use confirms its dominance—frozen fries achieve deep-fry texture in 15 minutes, and a whole 8 lb. chicken roasts evenly thanks to three adjustable rack positions. The 5-in-1 cooking modes (air fry, bake, broil, convection bake, toast) cover nearly every kitchen need, and the 60-minute timer with Stay On is ideal for batch cooking. While it lacks a rapid reheat function, its mechanical dials offer tactile precision over digital touchscreens that can feel finicky. It’s not the quietest model, but the performance more than compensates.

Against the 31191, this model offers superior heat output and visibility, though it misses French doors and a digital display. It’s the ideal middle ground between simplicity and advanced features, perfect for cooks who want pro-level results without complex programming. If you demand maximum versatility, power, and clarity in one sleek build, this Hamilton Beach XL oven sets the new standard—outperforming rivals in both speed and consistency.

This roasting beast is engineered for one thing: perfectly roasted meats with self-basting rotisserie magic. The revolving skewer locks in juices, turning a 5 lb. chicken into a crispy, golden masterpiece with hands-off ease. With convection baking that cuts cooking time by up to 25%, it outpaces traditional ovens, while the extra-large interior fits two 12” pizzas or 9×13” pans side by side, making it ideal for batch cooking or family feasts.

In practice, the rotisserie function shines—chickens come out evenly browned with minimal effort, and the drip tray captures grease efficiently, reducing mess. Baking casseroles or broiling salmon works well, though the lack of air frying limits versatility for health-conscious users. The 2-hour auto shutoff is reliable, but the analog knobs, while durable, don’t offer the precision of digital controls. It’s not the fastest preheater, but once hot, it maintains temperature steadily.

Compared to the 31123DA, this model offers larger capacity and rotisserie capability, but sacrifices the roll-top door convenience. It’s tailor-made for roasting enthusiasts or those who regularly cook for crowds. If your kitchen revolves around slow-roasted meats and large dishes, this Hamilton Beach oven delivers unmatched performance, outclassing most in its category when it comes to moisture retention and even heat distribution.

This convection champion redefines even cooking with a high-efficiency fan system that circulates heat 25% faster than standard ovens, slashing cook times and eliminating cold zones. The roll-top door stays fully open, giving unobstructed access—perfect for checking cookies or flipping chicken without burns or spills. With 150–450°F precision control and two rack positions, it handles everything from delicate pastries to hearty broiled salmon with confidence.

Testing reveals exceptional consistency—toast browns uniformly across six slices, and a 12” pizza cooks edge-to-center without rotation. The 30-minute timer with Stay On is ideal for extended bakes, and the slide-out crumb tray makes cleanup effortless. However, it lacks air frying, so crispy fries require extra oil or a separate appliance. While it heats quickly, the interior lighting is dim, making nighttime monitoring tricky.

When compared to the B06X3T8D1R, this model offers larger capacity and superior convection performance, though it’s pricier and less compact. It’s perfect for cooks who prioritize even baking and fast results over bells and whistles. If you want reliable, no-nonsense convection power in a user-friendly design, this Hamilton Beach oven dominates its niche, delivering professional-grade cooking without complexity.

This space-saving marvel merges a full toaster oven with a long-slot 2-slice toaster into one compact unit—ideal for kitchens where every inch counts. The 60-minute timer with Stay On supports long bakes, while the 5-shade selector ensures perfect toast, browning 40% faster than many competitors. With 450°F max heat and 16.5L interior space, it handles small pizzas, frozen fries, and casseroles with ease.

In real use, the dual functionality shines—you can toast bread while baking a casserole below, saving time and energy. The keep-warm function is a thoughtful touch for busy mornings. However, the 9″ pizza limit and 3/4 lb. fry capacity restrict family-sized meals, and the toaster slot isn’t wide enough for thick artisanal breads. It also lacks convection, so browning isn’t as crisp as in higher-end models.

Against the 31143, this model offers better space efficiency and multitasking, but sacrifices slice capacity and convection. It’s perfect for singles, couples, or dorm rooms where minimal counter space is non-negotiable. If you need two appliances in one without sacrificing core cooking performance, this Hamilton Beach combo maximizes utility in a tiny footprint, outperforming standalone units in compact convenience.

This budget-savvy standout proves you don’t need to spend big for crispy, oil-free meals. With Sure-Crisp air circulation, it delivers golden fries and juicy chicken using little to no oil—perfect for health-focused cooks. The 4-slice capacity and 9” pizza fit suit singles or couples, and the 200–450°F range ensures precise control across toast, bake, air fry, and broil modes.

In testing, it air fried frozen fries effectively, though slightly less crispy than 1700W models. Baking a small cake worked well, but hotspots appeared near the rear, requiring rotation. The simple analog controls are easy to use, but lack timers or presets. Still, for the price, it includes air fry basket, bake pan, and broil rack, offering full functionality without fluff.

Versus the B0949DJ2LN, it’s smaller and less powerful but wins on affordability and footprint. It’s ideal for first-time users or minimalists who want air frying without clutter. If you’re after a no-frills, entry-level air fryer toaster combo, this Hamilton Beach model delivers solid performance at a steal, outperforming many in its price range.

This compact dynamo packs five essential cooking modes into a space-conscious design, making it a top pick for kitchens short on real estate. The bagel and keep-warm functions add thoughtful versatility, while the 1100W heating system handles daily tasks like toasting, reheating, and small bakes with ease. Its 200–450°F range and 30-minute timer offer solid control for such a small unit.

In practice, it toasts four slices evenly and broils salmon fillets well, though larger dishes don’t fit. The simple knob interface is intuitive, especially for older users or tech-averse cooks. However, the lack of convection limits crispiness, and the interior is tight for 9×5” loaf pans. It’s not built for air frying or large meals, but it excels at basic, fast cooking.

Compared to the 31156, it lacks a combo toaster design but offers better oven usability. It’s perfect for students, small apartments, or secondary kitchens. If you want a no-hassle, compact oven for everyday basics, this Hamilton Beach model maximizes function in minimal space, outshining bulkier units in simplicity and ease.

This family-sized powerhouse is built for feeding crowds fast, with a spacious 0.9 cu. ft. cavity that roasts an 8 lb. chicken or bakes a 12” pizza with room to spare. The French doors open sideways, keeping countertops clear and allowing one-handed access—ideal for busy kitchens. With 1700 watts and six digital modes, including rapid reheat, it slashes meal prep time, getting leftovers hot in just 10 minutes.

Real-world tests confirm its speed and capacity—frozen meals reheat quickly without drying, and air-fried wings come out crispy and evenly cooked thanks to Sure-Crisp technology. The LCD screen and dial interface are intuitive, showing time, temp, and mode at a glance. However, the French doors require side clearance, making it unsuitable for tight spaces. It also lacks a rotisserie, so roasting isn’t as dynamic as in the 31107D.

Versus the B0FD57CGW8, it offers larger capacity and rapid reheat, but the offset handle on the rival provides better visibility. It’s ideal for families or entertainers who need fast, large-volume cooking. If you want a digital, high-capacity air fryer oven that handles weeknight dinners and parties alike, this Hamilton Beach model delivers unmatched family-focused performance.